Rogers handball penalty in Chelsea's defeat by Leeds upheld as correct under law
What happened
Chelsea's Morgan Rogers conceded a penalty for handball during his side's 4-1 home defeat by Leeds on Saturday, a decision that gave the visitors the lead for the first time and reopened debate about intent in the Premier League's handball law. BBC Sport reported that referee Michael Oliver pointed to the spot and that the video assistant referee, Michael Salisbury, did not intervene, with the decision judged correct under the current interpretation.
Report details
The ruling rested on two factors referees weigh in handball cases. Because Jayden Bogle's shot came from distance, a defender is considered to have more time to adjust his body and avoid contact. More importantly, when Bogle shot, Rogers' arm was not raised but came up into the flight of the ball. Had the arm stayed in its original position, lower and level with his midriff, there would have been no offence. The principle applied is that if the ball would have hit the body without touching the arm, the contact is treated as having no impact; here, the raised arm deflected the ball away, which is regarded as a deliberate act that overrides other considerations.
There was a question over whether the ball struck too high on the arm to count, but BBC Sport reported it appeared to be in the punishable "red zone", leaving little ground for a VAR review. The report compared the case to a penalty awarded to Leeds last season, when Everton defender James Tarkowski leaned into a shot with his arm tucked tightly to his side. Everton manager David Moyes called that decision "wrong", but the report said it was correct in law because the deliberate act of leaning into the ball's path made the arm's position irrelevant.
Not everyone accepted the call. BBC Match of the Day pundit Alan Shearer said he disagreed with the penalty, arguing that officials are not allowed to use common sense. "Morgan Rogers is not deliberately trying to stop the ball. He just doesn't want it hitting him in the face," Shearer said, while adding that Chelsea were deservedly beaten by a stronger, more physical and better-organised Leeds. Chelsea boss Xabi Alonso told Sky Sports the decision was "quite a harsh" and that he would not have given a penalty, though he said he did not want to make a big thing of it. The report noted Rogers could argue he raised his arm to protect his face, a mitigating factor that usually applies only when players raise their hands to the face rather than using the arm as a barrier.
The BBC report placed the incident against a wider trend: handball penalties are rarer in the Premier League than in Europe's other top five leagues. Last season produced 22 handball penalties in 380 English top-flight games, the lowest tally, compared with 36 in Spain's La Liga and 38 in Italy's Serie A. This season the Premier League had three in 106 matches. The report said the feeling among Premier League clubs is that handball is in a good place, with an offence requiring the arm to be fully extended away from the body, raised, or used deliberately.


Article discussion