Premier League panel logs joint-record six on-field errors in one weekend
What happened
The Premier League's Key Match Incidents Panel ruled there were six on-field refereeing errors in the most recent round of matches, the joint-highest total it has recorded for a single weekend, BBC Sport reported. The figure matches the last time six mistakes were logged, early in the 2023-24 season. The panel's count covers on-field decisions only and does not include correct VAR interventions that fixed errors, such as the red card shown to Brentford's Igor Thiago.
Report details
The five-member panel reviews contentious incidents each week and votes on whether the referee and the video assistant referee reached the correct outcome. Its votes feed a merit table that contributes 50% of referees' salary bonus payments, according to the report. The panel was scrapped in the Scottish Premiership this summer amid club frustration with its voting patterns, but it retains a central role in the Premier League.
Among the incidents the panel unanimously judged incorrect was Coventry's Caleb Yirenkyi appearing to have his hair pulled inside the area by Everton's James Tarkowski, with no penalty awarded. The panel said Tarkowski held Yirenkyi's hair and felt VAR should have intervened. It also voted 5-0 that Arsenal's Kai Havertz was wrongly denied a penalty after being pulled down by Hull City's Nobel Mendy; VAR official Michael Oliver sent referee Farai Hallam to the pitchside monitor, but no penalty was given because Havertz was offside. The panel said that although Havertz was clearly offside, there was a clear and impactful holding action by Mendy beforehand.
Other decisions drew split votes. The panel voted 2-3 that Thierno Barry's 61st-minute opener for Everton against Coventry was incorrect on the field because the ball probably struck his hand accidentally, but 5-0 that there was no VAR intervention because available footage was not conclusive. It voted 0-5 that Crystal Palace's stoppage-time penalty against Liverpool for a foul by Milos Kerkez on Dario Osorio was incorrect on the field, with contact inevitable, but 5-0 that it was not a clear and obvious error. Ipswich's 72nd-minute penalty against Bournemouth for a foul by Lewis Cook on Abdoul Ouattara was judged incorrect 1-4 on the field, with a 4-1 vote against VAR intervention. A potential second yellow for Bournemouth's Marcus Tavernier was ruled incorrect 2-3 on the field, with no VAR intervention possible; the panel said Tavernier clearly and deliberately delayed the restart.
Several high-profile incidents were upheld as correct. Leeds United's Jayden Bogle caught Tottenham's Mathys Tel high on the ankle without a red card; the panel voted 3-2 that the on-field decision and VAR were correct, with two members believing the challenge merited a red. Chelsea's Cole Palmer going down under Sunderland's Luke O'Nien was judged correct 4-1, with the panel saying contact should have brought a free-kick outside the area. Sunderland's penalty when Levi Colwill was ruled to have tripped Brian Bobbey was upheld 5-0, and a possible foul by Senne Lammens on Aston Villa goalkeeper Zion Suzuki before Patrick Dorgu's 96th-minute equaliser was also upheld 5-0.
The report noted that Tottenham lodged a complaint over Bogle's challenge and that Liverpool argued against the late Palace penalty. It added that the panel does not mirror supporter opinion but applies the laws of the game and the Premier League's expected interpretation, including a high bar for VAR intervention. The report observed that six on-field mistakes, plus the Thiago red card, is clearly a high number, and that fans struggle to understand why such errors are tolerated rather than corrected.


Article discussion