Premier LeagueClub updates

Tim Vickery warns Manchester City case could threaten Premier League's global dominance

TrivelaArticle updated:

What happened

English journalist Tim Vickery has warned that the Manchester City financial-infringement case could put the Premier League's global dominance at risk, arguing that the league's business model depends almost entirely on selling broadcast rights abroad. Vickery made the comments on Trivela's programme "Futebol em Contexto", where he was speaking alongside Nelson Coltro. The Trivela column reported his remarks.

Trivela ↗

Report details

Vickery said the domestic market has no room left to grow and that the league's future lies outside England. "It's a nightmare for the business model. The Premier League is totally dependent on selling abroad," he said, adding that the English economy is not doing well and that the league has already extracted what it could from the domestic market. He recalled that the world once watched Italy's Serie A and no longer does, and said history teaches that every empire ends. "The owners of the Premier League now have to be very, very worried," he said.

He traced how the league built its reach, noting it began in 1992 and took time to win over a global audience, becoming especially strong in Asia and Africa with a reach that American sports do not have. In Brazil, he said, the turning point came with ESPN's broadcasts, when, in his words, almost everyone regrettably became an Arsenal or Chelsea fan.

Vickery compared the City case to the Calciopoli scandal that shook Italian football in 2006, saying it accounted for a large part of Serie A's decline. He argued the City case is less serious morally, saying no one was robbed on the pitch, and pointed to worse things coming out of Spain, with big clubs buying referee consultants. Coltro noted the case does not compare to Brazil's 2005 match-fixing scandal, known as the Máfia do Apito, and Vickery agreed while adding a caveat. "That gives a bit of leeway, so to speak. But even so, if this ends with the club's lawyers being more important than the strikers, the possibility of losing global audience is big. There are other championships in the world, there are other stars in the world," he warned.

On the outcome, Vickery said any decision will not be based only on what is fair for City but on the consequences for the Premier League as a whole. He said it would not surprise him if financial rules were relaxed somewhat in future and owners were allowed to spend more of their money, since enough Premier League owners would favour that because it consolidates their position against rivals without the same spending capacity. Coltro argued for the opposite path, an exemplary punishment to protect the league's image, which he considers the world's biggest for at least 10 to 15 years and which he said is already in crisis.

Vickery closed with a direct message to the league's regulators, urging them to pay attention to Coltro's words because he represents their target audience. He said English fans will watch the Premier League under any circumstances, but the league needs to sell abroad, and Coltro's view will be very strong in the markets where it must sell its product to maintain its current level.

Torcedor sozinho no estádio do Sunderland (Foto: IMAGO / Action Plus)
Torcedor sozinho no estádio do Sunderland (Foto: IMAGO / Action Plus)Trivela ↗
O CEO do Manchester City, Ferran Soriano, acompanha jogo contra o Ipswich. Foto: IMAGO / APL
O CEO do Manchester City, Ferran Soriano, acompanha jogo contra o Ipswich. Foto: IMAGO / APLTrivela ↗

Original report

What to follow next

Team & schedule · Manchester City

Source: SportXG match data

Recent results in this competition · newest first

  1. Loss
  2. Loss
  3. Loss
  4. Win
  5. Win

Next scheduled match in this competition

Manchester City vs Fulham
Team profile

Article discussion

    0/280
    Plain text, up to 280 characters. No links.Sign in to comment