BBC Sport: Bottom three face historic relegation odds despite tight table
What happened
Crystal Palace, Sunderland and Manchester United occupy the Premier League relegation zone as the season resumes on Saturday, and BBC Sport has examined what the position after 10 games has meant historically. Palace and United return with new managers, Thomas Frank and Mauricio Pochettino respectively, while Sunderland have kept faith with Regis le Bris rather than pressing the panic button.
Report details
According to the BBC's analysis of every Premier League season since the league moved to 20 teams in 1995-96, the current bottom three have cause for concern. In 19 of the previous 31 seasons, a figure of 61%, only one of the bottom three sides after 10 games avoided relegation. The BBC defined the bottom three as the three sides with the worst record after 10 games rather than simply those in the relegation zone after matchweek 10, because in some seasons a team had played nine games by that point. Only in 10 seasons, 32%, did two or more of the bottom three stay up, and that has not happened in any of the past eight campaigns. The last time more than one team avoided the drop was 2017-18, when all three survived; that has happened only twice, although only twice have all three sides been relegated. Of the 93 previous teams in the bottom three after 10 games, 41 survived and 52 were relegated, a survival rate of 44%.
This is the third time Palace have been bottom after 10 games. On both previous occasions they survived and finished 11th, under Tony Pulis in 2013-14 and Roy Hodgson in 2017-18. Both managers, like Frank, were appointed early in the season after poor starts under Ian Holloway and Frank de Boer respectively. The 2013-14 season is the only previous time Sunderland and Palace were the bottom two at this stage; Sunderland also survived that year through a late escape under Gus Poyet. This is the first time United have been in the bottom three after 10 games of a Premier League season. The BBC noted that, given the club's size and resources, it is unlikely they will go down, although the team in 18th place at this stage has been relegated in each of the past six seasons.
There is also evidence this may not be a standard season. Palace's seven points are the most the bottom side after 10 games have had for 24 years, while Sunderland's eight points are the most the side in 19th place have had for 16 years. Only five points separate the bottom half, with Tottenham 11th on 12 points and Palace bottom on seven, the smallest gap at this stage for 24 years. The highest finish by a team in the bottom three after 10 games is eighth, achieved by Bolton in 2003-04, Tottenham in 2008-09 and Everton in 2017-18. Only nine points separate Chelsea in fifth and Palace, the smallest gap at this stage for 16 years. The BBC also noted that the most points a team have had after 10 games of a 38-game season and still been relegated is 14, by Joe Royle's Manchester City in 2000-01, while Eddie Howe's Bournemouth were ninth with 13 points in 2019-20 but went down on the final day. In 2002-03, West Ham were relegated on the final day with 42 points, the most a side have been relegated with in Premier League history, and the BBC suggested 40 points might not be enough to survive this season.


Article discussion