Premier LeagueClub updates

Premier League VAR explanation fails to clarify disallowed Haaland goal in Manchester City draw with Fulham

Football365Article updated:

What happened

Manchester City's 1-1 draw with Fulham at the Etihad Stadium on Saturday was overshadowed by a disallowed first-half Erling Haaland goal that the Premier League's own explanation has failed to clarify, according to a Football365 report. The hosts were held without a Premier League win for a fourth consecutive game, with Rodrigo Muniz giving Fulham a 16th-minute lead and Elliot Anderson equalising in the 58th minute.

Football365 ↗

Report details

Muniz scored from Fulham's first shot on target after the visitors broke down the right through former Manchester City player Oscar Bobb. Bobb cut inside and laid the ball to Muniz, who controlled it and sent a whipped effort into the top right corner. The report states Fulham led at the break away to Manchester City for the first time ever, before Anderson hammered a low volley under the goalkeeper from just outside the area just before the hour mark. That proved the final goal of the game.

The central controversy came in the 25th minute. Iliman Ndiaye crossed from the right flank and found Haaland's run at the back post, but the Norwegian did not strike the ball cleanly and bundled it goalwards. Goalkeeper Bernd Leno initially kept it out before apparently dropping the ball, allowing Haaland to push it home. Referee Tom Bramall hesitated for around 10 seconds before disallowing the goal for a foul on Leno, prompting frustration from the Manchester City players. The report says the time between the ball crossing the line and play resuming was very quick, drawing widespread criticism of the officiating.

Former Premier League referee Mike Dean, speaking on the Soccer Saturday panel, said he believed it should have been a goal. He said the keeper was going backwards and pushed the ball away from his hands, and that Haaland had every right to go for it. Dean noted the referee did not give the goal straight away, spoke to his assistant, and then awarded a foul on-field about five to ten seconds later, adding he would like to know why and that an extra ten seconds would have done no harm. He said the panel initially thought it was a foul but changed their minds after seeing more replays.

Former Manchester City goalkeeper Joe Hart was also perplexed. He said the rules indicate Leno had his hands and fingertips on the ball, and that he had to think about why that provision exists, as he had been under the impression a goalkeeper needed control of the ball. Hart said the rule appears designed to protect the goalkeeper in general rather than for that specific circumstance.

The Premier League Match Centre's statement on X did little to resolve the confusion, per the report. It said the referee's call of a free-kick to Fulham and no goal to Manchester City was checked and confirmed by VAR, with the goalkeeper deemed to be in control of the ball. The VAR explanation stated the ball was in control between both hands and then played out of that possession by the attacker before going into the net. The report says this would help if it were true, noting that social media users and Manchester City fans argued Leno was not in control and had actually dropped the ball when Haaland knocked it in.

The goal remained disallowed, and the remaining 72 minutes produced no winner for Manchester City. The report described Fulham as more than deserving of their first point against Manchester City in over 15 years. Going into the interval, TNT Sports commentator and former Chelsea player Joe Cole said Fulham had played into pockets and broken off with runners, and that City needed fight and spirit, expecting harsh words at half-time and changes. The draw extended Manchester City's winless Premier League run, with the report noting an away trip to Arsenal looming.

Original report

Competition hub

Article discussion

    0/280
    Plain text, up to 280 characters. No links.Sign in to comment

    Read next

    1. Same competitionPremier League

      Liverpool and Manchester United meet at Anfield with history on the line

      Trivela
    2. Same competitionPremier League

      Williams-Barnett impresses on first Spurs start

      BBC Sport
    3. Same competitionPremier League

      Madueke earns Arsenal 2-2 draw at Newcastle after Raya injury

      ANTARA News
    4. Same competitionPremier League

      Redknapp doubts Kepa can fill in for injured Raya after Arsenal's draw at Newcastle

      Football365