Premier LeagueClub updates

Football365 lists eight Premier League loans already looking futile, led by Garnacho at Aston Villa

Football365Article updated:

What happened

Football365 has published a list of eight loan moves involving Premier League clubs that it says already look like a waste of time, headlined by Alejandro Garnacho's spell at Aston Villa. The outlet framed the piece around the question of who will be "this season's Harvey Elliott," referring to the Liverpool player's unproductive loan at Villa last season, when the club's reluctance to trigger a permanent transfer left him on the sidelines. Football365 noted that January could offer some underused loanees a chance to escape, and that the list covers only the current season.

Football365 ↗

Report details

On Garnacho, the report said the winger is on loan at Villa from Chelsea and is yet to start a game in any competition, having made seven substitute appearances for a total of 95 minutes. He was not even in the squad for three of Villa's past four league matches. Football365 criticised Villa for again agreeing to an obligation to buy depending on appearance criteria, having done so with Elliott the previous season. The outlet said there was a sense in the summer that if Unai Emery wanted Garnacho it must be for good reason, citing how the manager had taken Nicolas Jackson up a level, but that it is not happening. Unlike Elliott, Garnacho did not play for his parent club in the same season as completing the loan, so a January exit may be possible; the report added that at 22 he should not be a lost cause, but called him an expensive mistake for Chelsea and a luxury on the bench for Villa.

Other entries follow a similar pattern of limited minutes. Promise David, on loan at Brighton from Union SG, has made four appearances, all as a substitute, only two of them in the Premier League, the most recent in Brighton's first game in September; Football365 said an obligatory purchase clause requiring more than £20m after a certain number of games appears to be holding him back. Goalkeeper Altay Bayindir, on loan at Celta de Vigo from Manchester United, has played only in a 5-0 Copa del Rey win over Salamanca, with Ionut Radu remaining the regular starter and no Europa League chance given. Robinio Vaz, loaned by Roma to Hull City after a €25m January move, is yet to start a Premier League match, had to drop to an under-21s game, and his longest outing besides an hour in the EFL Cup against Sunderland lasted 22 minutes.

At Leeds United, Jean-Matteo Bahoya, on loan from Eintracht Frankfurt, has made three substitute appearances of one, four and six minutes and was left out of the squad entirely before the international break. Daniel Farke said the player needs to add physicality, improve his decision making and finishing, and that there are several aspects to work on; Football365 suggested the more than £25m obligation to buy may explain Leeds' caution. Evann Guessand, back on loan at Crystal Palace from Aston Villa after a previous loan there, has not started a Premier League game and has appeared only in the EFL Cup against Fulham since August, having been left out of Pierre Sage's Europa League squad; the report said Palace's intentions on a permanent deal appear unchanged and that Sage's expected successor, Thomas Frank, may think more highly of him.

Souza, on loan at Porto from Tottenham, is yet to start in either the league or the Champions League, though Football365 noted he made his first start in the cup in late October and got a full half on his league debut, calling it a slow start for the 20-year-old. The final entry is Elliott himself, now on loan at Valencia from Liverpool: all his La Liga minutes have come from the bench, he was sent off on his sixth league appearance, and his Copa del Rey goal came against Tavernes, who usually play in the sixth tier. With no option or obligation for Valencia to buy, Football365 said he could return to Liverpool next summer, two years after they thought they had moved him on for good.

Original report

What to follow next

Team & schedule · Aston Villa

Source: SportXG match data

Recent results in this competition · newest first

  1. Draw
  2. Draw
  3. Win
  4. Win
  5. Draw

Next scheduled match in this competition

Aston Villa vs Sunderland
Team profile

Article discussion

    0/280
    Plain text, up to 280 characters. No links.Sign in to comment

    Read next

    1. Same teamPremier League

      Aston Villa extend Victor Lindelof's contract until 2028

      ANTARA News
    2. Same teamPremier League

      Alysson's Breakthrough at Aston Villa: From Injury Struggles to Old Trafford Star

      Trivela
    3. Same teamPremier League

      Emery Calls Villa's 4-4 Draw at Man Utd a 'Defeat' After Late Collapse

      Football365
    4. Same teamPremier League

      Ornstein: INEOS set to keep faith with Carrick at Man Utd despite Villa test

      Football365