MLSClub updates

Vancouver Caps writer backs Musa, Sullivan and Damet in end-of-season awards

The Third SubArticle updated:

What happened

A Vancouver Caps-focused column published by The Third Sub on Monday set out the writer's own picks for MLS end-of-season awards, arguing that the league's voting media made "a few errors in judgement" when the finalists were unveiled the previous week. The piece was framed around the international break, with the writer describing the current period as one of "suspended animation" while waiting for the playoffs to begin.

The Third Sub ↗

Report details

The writer called the MVP race undramatic, saying Lionel Messi was both the best and most valuable player because without him the Miami side "would be in the play in game." The writer noted having objected when Messi won the award two years earlier but not this time. The main complaint was the omission of Petar Musa from the finalists, with the writer describing him as one of the league's most prolific scorers and central to FC Dallas finishing second in the West, and arguing that voters not choosing Messi should choose Musa.

On coach of the year, the writer expected BJ Callaghan to win and called that "totally fine," citing leading a team to the points record as a worthy accomplishment. The writer nonetheless favoured Damet, arguing that while everyone expected Nashville to be good, St. Louis was widely picked as a bottom feeder in the West and Damet got them playing good football and reset the team's culture. Callaghan, Jesper Sorensen and Ryan Richter were listed as honourable mentions.

For defender of the year, the writer found it "a bit silly" that Nashville supplied all three finalists, acknowledging the record for fewest goals conceded in a 34-game season but noting the Caps conceded fewer expected goals, which the writer felt should have been recognised among the finalists. The writer had no issue with Maxwell Woledzi winning, describing him as rare in being both good on the ball and good at defending and as the leader of the backline for the league's best team. Tate Johnson, Edier Ocampo and Osaze Urhoghide were honourable mentions.

Goalkeeper of the year was cast as a two-horse race between Turner and Brian Schwake, either of whom the writer considered deserving, with Turner judged more instrumental to his team's success even though Schwake held the edge in advanced statistics. The writer said Yohei Takaoka was "robbed" of a finalist nod in favour of Roman Burki, whom the writer called a below-average keeper this year. Schwake, Takaoka and Andrew Thomas were honourable mentions.

The newcomer award was expected to go to Antoine Griezmann, though the writer expressed a "mental block" about giving a year-long award to a player who joined midseason. The writer still praised Griezmann's 16 goals and eight assists on a middling Houston team as impressive, admitting to having mocked the Dynamo's designated player signing and getting it "totally wrong," calling him electric and Houston's most important player this season. Griezmann, Morgan Guilavogui and Andre Luiz were honourable mentions.

Cavan Sullivan of the Philadelphia Union was the writer's young player of the year, described as possibly the most obvious selection of all and arguably the most dominant player in MLS not named Lionel Messi, having redefined expectations for teenage players in the league. The writer called it a slam dunk while acknowledging it was harsh on an exciting group of young players.

The column also covered other items. Canada went up 3-0 before beating Guatemala 3-2 away, a closer result than they wanted but one that left them in excellent position to reach the CONCACAF Nations League semi-finals. Alphonso Davies' return was short-lived, as a hamstring injury will keep him out of the return leg against Guatemala. The writer also looked at Niko Sigur's rising stock after his move to France and continued call-ups. AFC Toronto won the Northern Super League title, beating Montreal 1-0.

Original report

Competition hub

Article discussion

    0/280
    Plain text, up to 280 characters. No links.Sign in to comment

    Read next

    1. Same competitionMLS

      Whitecaps close regular season with 2-0 win at Montreal on Decision Day

      The Third Sub
    2. Same competitionMLS

      Vancouver Whitecaps beat CF Montreal 2-0 to finish second

      The Third Sub
    3. Related topicLa Liga

      Rüdiger says two trophy-less years at Real Madrid would be 'horrible'

      AS
    4. Related topicPremier League

      Juan Mata announces retirement from playing at 38

      BBC Sport